Cookies help us run our site more efficiently.

By clicking “Accept”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. View our Privacy Policy for more information or to customize your cookie preferences.

How women led the activism that created the Superfund program

News Feed
Monday, April 22, 2024

Lois Gibbs became an activist after fighting to get her family and others evacuated from a contaminated neighborhood in Niagra Falls, N.Y., in the late 1970s. The Love Canal environmental disaster helped lead to the creation of the EPA’s Superfund program.The Environmental Protection Agency has decided not to take over the cleanup of the contaminated San Jacinto River Waste Pits Superfund site. Instead, the EPA will allow the responsible parties, McGinnis Industrial Maintenance Corporation and International Paper Company, to continue to manage the site, which consists of two pits for a now-defunct paper mill that dumped chemical waste there decades ago. One of the pits has been cleaned up. The second has continued to stagnate in the planning and design stages. Macie Kelly/Houston Public Media Shown in 2019, danger signs at the San Jacinto River Waste Pits indicate the water is contaminated.Earlier this year, the EPA issued a “Notice of Takeover” to the responsible parties before issuing this decision late last week. Jackie Medcalf of the Texas Health and Environment Alliance, who founded her organization after she and her family suffered numerous health problems while living near the waste pits, said in a statement the companies’ actions so far amount to “nothing more than a plan to create a plan.” And she told Houston Public Media that residents living in the area are disappointed and discouraged. “They’re tired of the EPA giving the companies opportunity after opportunity to come up with a plan that meets the EPA’s criteria,” Medcalf said. The waste pits are just one of 21 Superfund sites around Greater Houston. Those are polluted sites the EPA has named to its National Priorities List. Once a site has been named to that list, it becomes subject to federal oversight and special funding can be allocated to its cleanup, hence the term “Superfund.” But it wasn't always that way, that is until an environmental disaster known as Love Canal near Niagara Falls, N.Y., helped create the Superfund program. That story is told in a new documentary from the PBS series American Experience, called Poisoned Ground: The Tragedy at Love Canal, and it airs tonight at 9 on Houston Public Media, TV 8. VIDEO The documentary details how homes and schools were built atop and adjacent to chemical dumping grounds and how, in the late 1970s, residents — led mostly by women — fought to be moved out of the site. That disaster and their activism helped lead to the 1980 federal law that created the Superfund program. AP Photo/FileA boy living in the neighborhood affected by the Love Canal environmental disaster in Niagra Falls, N.Y., protests in 1978.Activist Lois Gibbs is featured prominently in the documentary. She lived in the contaminated neighborhood and became the face of the fight for its cleanup along with many other women who lived there. Another one of them was Debbie Curry (who was Debbie Cerrillo at the time). She said she and her children all suffered a laundry list of health problems during and after living in that neighborhood. And she explained why she kept fighting to get other families out even after hers was living elsewhere. “I had to fight for my children like a dog would for her puppies. She would do anything to keep them safe,” Curry said. "And that's what I was doing." More than 40 years later, those same kinds of fights continue, including here in Houston where Medcalf is perhaps the Lois Gibbs of Houston. In fact, Gibbs has been a mentor to Medcalf for several years now as Medcalf works for the cleanup of contaminated sites in our region. Courtesy: Jackie MedcalfJackie Medcalf (left) at the EPA headquarters in Washington, D.C. with Lois Gibbs (second from left).In an interview with Houston Matters producer Michael Hagerty, Medcalf explains how a project in a college science class helped her discover the many heavy metals contaminating the drinking water on her family’s property near the San Jacinto Waste Pits and about the many health problems she, her parents, and her family’s animals suffered while living there. She also talks about the challenges of these kinds of environmental fights and about the role women like Gibbs and Curry — and now she herself — often play in this activism. “It’s almost always women,” Medcalf said, adding that around 90 percent of the people she works with advocating for the cleanup of Superfund sites are women. “But more so than that, it’s almost always the moms,” she said. “The moms start recognizing something, whether it’s in their yard or with their children.” Courtesy: Jackie MedcalfActivists Lois Gibbs and Jackie Medcalf at the San Jacinto River Waste Pits Superfund site.Similarly, Medcalf’s mother was the one who noticed a lot of the health problems in her family and with their animals. She’s also the one who pushed Medcalf to start her organization. And now, Medcalf is a mother herself, something that helps her see the issue with even greater perspective. “I think it’s really great and powerful that women across the country — and really around the world — are oftentimes the ones that are behind these movements.” Medcalf says Gibbs and Curry paved the way for her to do the work to which she’s devoted the last 13 years of her life. “Nobody has more tenacity than an angry mama bear,” she said. Courtesy: Jackie MedcalfLois Gibbs awarding Jackie Medcalf with the Champion for Change award at an event marking the 40th anniversary of the fight over the Love Canal contamination site.

A new PBS documentary called "Poisoned Ground" tells their story. And a local activist shares how the actions of women across the country more than 40 years ago paved the way for her fight to clean up contaminated sites in Greater Houston.

Lois Gibbs protesting
Lois Gibbs became an activist after fighting to get her family and others evacuated from a contaminated neighborhood in Niagra Falls, N.Y., in the late 1970s. The Love Canal environmental disaster helped lead to the creation of the EPA’s Superfund program.

The Environmental Protection Agency has decided not to take over the cleanup of the contaminated San Jacinto River Waste Pits Superfund site.

Instead, the EPA will allow the responsible parties, McGinnis Industrial Maintenance Corporation and International Paper Company, to continue to manage the site, which consists of two pits for a now-defunct paper mill that dumped chemical waste there decades ago. One of the pits has been cleaned up. The second has continued to stagnate in the planning and design stages.

Danger signs at the San Jacinto River waste pits indicating that the water is contaminated. September 9, 2019

Macie Kelly/Houston Public Media

Shown in 2019, danger signs at the San Jacinto River Waste Pits indicate the water is contaminated.

Earlier this year, the EPA issued a “Notice of Takeover” to the responsible parties before issuing this decision late last week.

Jackie Medcalf of the Texas Health and Environment Alliance, who founded her organization after she and her family suffered numerous health problems while living near the waste pits, said in a statement the companies’ actions so far amount to “nothing more than a plan to create a plan.” And she told Houston Public Media that residents living in the area are disappointed and discouraged.

“They’re tired of the EPA giving the companies opportunity after opportunity to come up with a plan that meets the EPA’s criteria,” Medcalf said.

The waste pits are just one of 21 Superfund sites around Greater Houston. Those are polluted sites the EPA has named to its National Priorities List. Once a site has been named to that list, it becomes subject to federal oversight and special funding can be allocated to its cleanup, hence the term “Superfund.”

But it wasn't always that way, that is until an environmental disaster known as Love Canal near Niagara Falls, N.Y., helped create the Superfund program. That story is told in a new documentary from the PBS series American Experience, called Poisoned Ground: The Tragedy at Love Canal, and it airs tonight at 9 on Houston Public Media, TV 8.

The documentary details how homes and schools were built atop and adjacent to chemical dumping grounds and how, in the late 1970s, residents — led mostly by women — fought to be moved out of the site.

That disaster and their activism helped lead to the 1980 federal law that created the Superfund program.

A boy protests the Love Canal environmental disaster

AP Photo/File

A boy living in the neighborhood affected by the Love Canal environmental disaster in Niagra Falls, N.Y., protests in 1978.

Activist Lois Gibbs is featured prominently in the documentary. She lived in the contaminated neighborhood and became the face of the fight for its cleanup along with many other women who lived there.

Another one of them was Debbie Curry (who was Debbie Cerrillo at the time). She said she and her children all suffered a laundry list of health problems during and after living in that neighborhood. And she explained why she kept fighting to get other families out even after hers was living elsewhere.

“I had to fight for my children like a dog would for her puppies. She would do anything to keep them safe,” Curry said. "And that's what I was doing."

More than 40 years later, those same kinds of fights continue, including here in Houston where Medcalf is perhaps the Lois Gibbs of Houston. In fact, Gibbs has been a mentor to Medcalf for several years now as Medcalf works for the cleanup of contaminated sites in our region.

Jackie Medcalf at the EPA headquarters

Courtesy: Jackie Medcalf

Jackie Medcalf (left) at the EPA headquarters in Washington, D.C. with Lois Gibbs (second from left).

In an interview with Houston Matters producer Michael Hagerty, Medcalf explains how a project in a college science class helped her discover the many heavy metals contaminating the drinking water on her family’s property near the San Jacinto Waste Pits and about the many health problems she, her parents, and her family’s animals suffered while living there.

She also talks about the challenges of these kinds of environmental fights and about the role women like Gibbs and Curry — and now she herself — often play in this activism.

“It’s almost always women,” Medcalf said, adding that around 90 percent of the people she works with advocating for the cleanup of Superfund sites are women.

“But more so than that, it’s almost always the moms,” she said. “The moms start recognizing something, whether it’s in their yard or with their children.”

Lois Gibbs and Jackie Medcalf at the San Jacinto Waste Pits Superfund site

Courtesy: Jackie Medcalf

Activists Lois Gibbs and Jackie Medcalf at the San Jacinto River Waste Pits Superfund site.

Similarly, Medcalf’s mother was the one who noticed a lot of the health problems in her family and with their animals. She’s also the one who pushed Medcalf to start her organization. And now, Medcalf is a mother herself, something that helps her see the issue with even greater perspective.

“I think it’s really great and powerful that women across the country — and really around the world — are oftentimes the ones that are behind these movements.”

Medcalf says Gibbs and Curry paved the way for her to do the work to which she’s devoted the last 13 years of her life.

“Nobody has more tenacity than an angry mama bear,” she said.

Lois Gibbs and Jackie Medcalf

Courtesy: Jackie Medcalf

Lois Gibbs awarding Jackie Medcalf with the Champion for Change award at an event marking the 40th anniversary of the fight over the Love Canal contamination site.
Read the full story here.
Photos courtesy of

Lynx on the Loose in Scotland Highlight Debate Over Reintroducing Species Into the Wild

Scottish environmental activists want to reintroduce the lynx into the forests of the Highlands

LONDON (AP) — Scottish environmental activists want to reintroduce the lynx into the forests of the Highlands. But not this way.At least two lynx, a medium-sized wildcat extinct in Scotland for hundreds of years, were spotted in the Highlands on Wednesday, raising concerns that a private breeder had illegally released the predators into the wild.Two cats were captured on Thursday, but authorities are continuing their search after two others were seen early Friday near Killiehuntly in the Cairngorms National Park. Wildlife authorities are setting traps in the area so they can humanely capture the lynx and take them to the Edinburgh Zoo, where the captured cats are already in quarantine, said David Field, chief executive of the Royal Zoological Society of Scotland.The hunt highlights a campaign by some activists to reintroduce lynx to help control the deer population and symbolize Scotland’s commitment to wildlife diversity. While no one knows who released the cats, wildlife experts speculate that it was either someone who took matters into their own hands because they were frustrated by the slow process of securing government approval for the project, or an opponent who wants to create problems that will block the reintroduction effort.“Scotland has a history of illicit guerrilla releases,” said Darragh Hare, a research fellow at the University of Oxford’s Wildlife Conservation Research Unit, citing releases of beavers and pine martins. But doing it right, in a way that everyone can have their say, is important.“If there’s going to be any lynx introduction into Scotland or elsewhere, the process of doing it the right way, even if it takes longer, is the most important thing,” he added.Lynx disappeared from Scotland between 500 and 1,300 years ago possibly because of hunting and loss of their woodland habitat.Efforts to reintroduce the cats to the wild have been underway since at least 2021 when a group calling itself Lynx to Scotland commissioned a study of public attitudes toward the proposal. The group is still working to secure government approval for a trial reintroduction in a defined area with a limited number of lynx.Lynx are “shy and elusive woodland hunters” that pose no threat to humans, the group says. They have been successfully reintroduced in other European countries, including Germany, France and Switzerland.Supporters of the reintroduction on Thursday issued a statement deploring the premature, illegal release of the cats.“The Lynx to Scotland Project is working to secure the return of lynx to the Scottish Highlands, but irresponsible and illegal releases such as this are entirely counterproductive,” said Peter Cairns, executive director of SCOTLAND: The Big Picture, a group of rewilding advocates that is part of the project.The issues surrounding the potential reintroduction of lynx were on display during a Scottish Parliament debate on the issue that took place in 2023.While advocates highlighted the benefits of reducing a deer population that is damaging Scotland’s forests, opponents focused on the potential threat to sheep and ground-nesting birds.“Lynx have been away from this country for 500 years, and now is just not the time to bring them back,” said Edward Mountain, a lawmaker from the opposition Conservative Party who represents the Highlands.Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.Photos You Should See - Sept. 2024

Will Biden Pardon Steven Donziger, Who Faced Retaliation for Suing Chevron over Oil Spill in Amazon?

Massachusetts Congressmember Jim McGovern calls on President Biden to pardon environmental activist Steven Donziger, who has been targeted for years by oil and gas giant Chevron. Donziger sued Chevron on behalf of farmers and Indigenous peoples who suffered the adverse health effects of oil drilling in the Ecuadorian Amazon. “I visited Ecuador. I saw what Chevron did. It is disgusting” and “grotesque,” says McGovern. “Donziger stood up for these people who had no voice.” In return, Chevron has spent millions prosecuting him instead of holding itself to account, he adds, while a pardon from the president would show that the system can still “stand up to corporate greed and excesses.”

Massachusetts Congressmember Jim McGovern calls on President Biden to pardon environmental activist Steven Donziger, who has been targeted for years by oil and gas giant Chevron. Donziger sued Chevron on behalf of farmers and Indigenous peoples who suffered the adverse health effects of oil drilling in the Ecuadorian Amazon. “I visited Ecuador. I saw what Chevron did. It is disgusting” and “grotesque,” says McGovern. “Donziger stood up for these people who had no voice.” In return, Chevron has spent millions prosecuting him instead of holding itself to account, he adds, while a pardon from the president would show that the system can still “stand up to corporate greed and excesses.”

Exxon sues California AG, environmental groups for disparaging its recycling initiatives

ExxonMobil on Monday sued California Attorney General Rob Bonta (D) and a group of environmental activist groups, alleging they colluded on a campaign of defamation against the oil giant’s plastic recycling initiative. The lawsuit, filed in the Eastern District of Texas, could signal a new legal strategy for the fossil fuel industry against environmentalists and...

ExxonMobil on Monday sued California Attorney General Rob Bonta (D) and a group of environmental activist groups, alleging they colluded on a campaign of defamation against the oil giant’s plastic recycling initiative. The lawsuit, filed in the Eastern District of Texas, could signal a new legal strategy for the fossil fuel industry against environmentalists and their allies in government. It argues Bonta defamed Exxon when he sued the company last September by alleging it engaged in a decades-long “campaign of deception” around the recyclability of single-use plastics. Bonta’s lawsuit accused Exxon of falsely promoting the idea that all plastics were recyclable. A report issued by the Center for Climate Integrity last February indicates only a small fraction of plastics can be meaningfully recycled in the sense of being turned into entirely new products. ExxonMobil claimed Bonta’s language in the lawsuit, as well as subsequent comments in interviews, hurt its business. “While posing under the banner of environmentalism, [the defendants] do damage to genuine recycling programs and to meaningful innovation,” the lawsuit states. The complaint also names four national and California-based environmental groups, the Sierra Club, San Francisco Baykeeper, Heal the Bay and the Surfrider Foundation, who sued the company at the same time as Bonta’s office. It accuses Bonta’s office of recruiting the organizations to file the suit. The lawsuit is another salvo in the company’s aggressive recent approach to critics after it sued activist investor group Arjuna Capital in 2024 over its plans to submit a proposal on Exxon greenhouse gas emissions. A Texas judge dismissed the lawsuit in June after Arjuna agreed not to submit the proposal. “This is another attempt from ExxonMobil to deflect attention from its own unlawful deception,” a spokesperson for Bonta’s office said in a statement to The Hill. “The Attorney General is proud to advance his lawsuit against ExxonMobil and looks forward to vigorously litigating this case in court.” The Hill has reached out to the other defendants for comment.

Texas shrimper's legal victory spurs $50 million revival of fishing community

A historic $50 million Clean Water Act settlement led by Diane Wilson is revitalizing the Texas Gulf Coast, funding a fishing cooperative, oyster farm and environmental restoration efforts.Dylan Baddour reports for Inside Climate News.In short:Diane Wilson’s 2019 settlement against Formosa Plastics has funded $50 million in projects, including a $20 million fishing cooperative and environmental programs.The Matagorda Bay Fishing Cooperative is forming sustainable oyster farms and plans to purchase local seafood operations to empower fishermen.The settlement also mandated Formosa to halt plastic pellet discharges, resulting in penalties contributing over $24 million to Wilson's trust fund.Key quote:“They cannot believe I would do this for the bay and the fishermen. It’s my home and I completely refuse to give it to that company to ruin.”— Diane Wilson, environmental advocate and shrimperWhy this matters:The settlement has created economic opportunities and strengthened environmental safeguards, potentially setting a precedent for communities impacted by industrial pollution. Restoring livelihoods while reducing plastic pollution showcases how citizen-led activism can challenge corporate power.

A historic $50 million Clean Water Act settlement led by Diane Wilson is revitalizing the Texas Gulf Coast, funding a fishing cooperative, oyster farm and environmental restoration efforts.Dylan Baddour reports for Inside Climate News.In short:Diane Wilson’s 2019 settlement against Formosa Plastics has funded $50 million in projects, including a $20 million fishing cooperative and environmental programs.The Matagorda Bay Fishing Cooperative is forming sustainable oyster farms and plans to purchase local seafood operations to empower fishermen.The settlement also mandated Formosa to halt plastic pellet discharges, resulting in penalties contributing over $24 million to Wilson's trust fund.Key quote:“They cannot believe I would do this for the bay and the fishermen. It’s my home and I completely refuse to give it to that company to ruin.”— Diane Wilson, environmental advocate and shrimperWhy this matters:The settlement has created economic opportunities and strengthened environmental safeguards, potentially setting a precedent for communities impacted by industrial pollution. Restoring livelihoods while reducing plastic pollution showcases how citizen-led activism can challenge corporate power.

Rare, teeny tiny snail could be at risk from huge lithium mine under construction just south of Oregon

Environmentalists and Native American activists are demanding that the U.S. Interior Department address what they say is new evidence that bolsters their concerns about Lithium Americas’ planned open pit mine at Thacker Pass.

RENO — Opponents of the nation’s largest lithium mine under construction want U.S. officials to investigate whether the Nevada project already has caused a drop in groundwater levels that could lead to extinction of a tiny snail being considered for endangered species protection.Environmentalists and Native American activists are demanding that the U.S. Interior Department address what they say is new evidence that bolsters their concerns about Lithium Americas’ planned open pit mine at Thacker Pass. The footprint of mine operations will span about 9 square miles.The fate of the snail takes center stage after a federal judge and an appeals court dismissed a previous attempt by Native American tribes to get federal agencies to recognize the sacred nature of the area. The tribes argued that the mine would infringe on lands where U.S. troops massacred dozens of their ancestors in 1865.Now, Western Watersheds Project and the group known as People of Red Mountain argue in a notice of intent to sue that the government and Canada-based Lithium Americas are failing to live up to promises to adequately monitor groundwater impacts.They say it’s alarming that an analysis of groundwater data from a nearby well that was conducted by Payton Gardner, an assistant professor of hydrogeology at the University of Montana, shows a drop in the water table of nearly 5 feet since 2018. Nevada regulators say they have no information so far that would confirm declining levels but have vowed to monitor the situation during the mine’s lifespan.No water, no snailNot much bigger than a grain of rice, the Kings River pyrg has managed to survive in 13 isolated springs within the basin surrounding the mine site. It’s the only place in the world where the snail lives.In some cases, the tiny creatures require only a few centimeters of water. But the margin for survival becomes more narrow if the groundwater system that feeds the springs begins to drop, said Paul Ruprecht, Nevada Director for Western Watersheds Project.“Even slight disruptions to its habitat could cause springs to run dry, driving it to extinction,” he said.Western Watersheds Project and the other opponents say the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service is violating the Endangered Species Act by failing to rule in a timely fashion on a 2022 petition to list the snail as threatened or endangered. The allegations outlined in the opponents’ notice follow requests for federal biologists to investigate whether groundwater drawdowns are being caused by exploratory drilling and other activities and whether there have been impacts to the springs.Without protection, Ruprecht fears the snail “will become another casualty of the lithium boom.”The Fish and Wildlife Service is conducting a review of the snail’s status, but the agency declined to comment on the requests for an investigation into the groundwater concerns.Poised to lead in lithium productionEfforts to mine gold and other minerals in Nevada and other parts of the West over the decades have spurred plenty of legal skirmishes over potential threats to wildlife and water supplies. Lithium is no exception, as demand for the metal critical to making batteries for electric vehicles is expected to continue to climb exponentially over the next decade.President Joe Biden made increased production of electric vehicles central to his energy agenda, and the U.S. Energy Department last year agreed to loan Lithium Americas more than $2 billion to help finance construction at Thacker Pass. On Dec. 23, Lithium Americas announced it had concluded a joint venture with General Motors Holdings LLC to develop and operate the mine.The mine about 30 miles south of the Oregon-Nevada border is the biggest in the works and closest to fruition in the U.S., followed by Ioneer’s Rhyolite Ridge project near the California line halfway between Reno and Las Vegas.And the Bureau of Land Management announced in late December that it was seeking comments on another proposed project in northeastern Nevada. Surge Battery Metals USA wants to explore for lithium in Elko County.Monitoring groundwaterRuprecht said reports filed by Lithium Americas’ environmental consultant with state regulators show the company no longer has permission to access private lands where several monitoring wells are located. That makes it harder to tell if flows have been impacted by past drilling, he said.Nevada regulators say they approved changes in 2024 to the monitoring plan to account for the loss of access to wells on private land.Prior data showed groundwater levels had remained stable from the 1960s to 2018. Construction started at the site in 2023.The Bureau of Land Management’s approval of the mine acknowledged some reduction in groundwater levels were possible but not for decades, and most likely would occur only if state regulators granted the company permission to dig below the water table.Lithium Americas spokesman Tim Crowley said it appears the mine’s opponents are “working to re-spin issues that have previously been addressed and resolved in court.” He pointed to 10 years of data collection by the company indicating the snail would not be affected by the project.-- The Associated Press

Suggested Viewing

Join us to forge
a sustainable future

Our team is always growing.
Become a partner, volunteer, sponsor, or intern today.
Let us know how you would like to get involved!

CONTACT US

sign up for our mailing list to stay informed on the latest films and environmental headlines.

Subscribers receive a free day pass for streaming Cinema Verde.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.